|
>>
|
No. 1250
I think this story is in need of a beta. Badly.
Basically, it's a POV piece where the narrator, Medic, doesn't sound anything like Medic. And I don't mean "write in accent" sounding like him. I mean that the speech patterns and inflections and personality of Medic are simply not evident in this narration. This doesn't read like it's being written by a middle-aged German doctor; it reads like it's written by a much younger person who isn't German at all and is probably female.
There are other problems evident in this too, but I'm just going to focus on how you're writing Medic here. I'm trying to help you out, here.
First off, Medic would probably not use slang, at all, if ever. The only way I can imagine him doing so would be in a very mocking manner, probably spitting back an expression Scout uses to make fun of him. Even if you're going for a Draco in Leather Pants treatment for Medic here, he would still come off as a jerk. A very prim and proper jerk who can be a classy motherfucker when he wants to be, mind you, but still a jerk.
Since Medic has kind of gotten the least characterization of any class outside of Pyro, he's very open-ended to write, and you can take him in multiple directions given what little characterization is given. Personally, I'm a fan of split-personality Medic; certainly capable of being caring and mother-hennish, like how a lot of people tend to play him, but he's also got a very nasty sadistic streak. He likes to carve people up. FOR SCIENCE. He likes blood and hurting and he's a creeper and this should be evident, even if you're trying to show a more sympathetic side to him. Being a Heavy/Medic shipper (hurrrr), I kind of use his relationship with Heavy to show his softer side, while writing him with some contempt for the rest of his teammates, who he sees as being idiots. There's always plenty of room for CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT!, but that's something your have to build up to.
Now, you may be thinking to yourself "I know all this about Medic, jeez, you fag," and you probably do. But the problem is that it's simply not being reflected in the way you write Medic. Read the lines in Medic's voice. Not your voice. Medic's. Does it sound natural coming out of his mouth? Would he choose that wording? Would he talk to the other characters that way? This isn't just dialog, either, this includes actions as well. To be fair, as I said, Medic's probably the hardest to write, since there's a lot less to work with than the other classes. But what little there is, you should hang on and use as much as you can.
I would suggest re-writing this, and getting a beta. If you want, I could do that for you. I've included my email. Drop me a line.
I'm here to help.
|